Which of the following is not a function of carbohydrates?

Which of the following is not a function of carbohydrates? What Carbs Can’t Do for Your Body

Introduction: The Essential Role of Carbohydrates

Carbohydrates also referred to as "carbs" are one of the three major macro-nutrients (including proteins and fats) that provide the body with essential energy. Yet, the potential function of the sugar molecule has remained to obscure and controversial during all those years as concerns health and fitness. There are those who recognize carb as the fuel source and those who realize carb as the primary driver of obesity/chronic disease. More recently, the movement of the carb free diet and the ketogenic diet have created a habit of cynicism about carbohydrates. Nevertheless, not to mention their controversial existence, carbohydrates play important, irreplaceable and many roles in a number of physiological functions.

In this article, we will explore not only the essential functions of carbohydrates but also clarify the limitations of carbs, focusing on what they cannot do for your body. This deeper understanding will help separate fact from fiction when it comes to carbs, enabling you to make more informed choices for your health.

Section 1: The Functions of Carbohydrates

1. Energy Source

Carbohydrates are primarily used to provide energy. If you take carbohydrates, the same are broken down into glucose (sugar) that is utilized as energy by your cells. Glucose has key functions in a wide variety of body processes including brain, muscles, and other tissues.

-Quick Energy: Simple sugars (e.g., sugars in fruits) are quickly hydrolyzed and absorbed by the organism. This burst of energy is helpful in high energy activities or in scenarios where a spurt of energy is needed immediately.

-Sustained Energy: In contrast, complex carbohydrates (i.e., complex carbohydrates found in cereals/grains, legumes and vegetables) are polymers of increasingly sugars. All these are low in digestible constituents, thus they bring sustained energy. The slower rate of digestion and consequently, a less sharp increase and decrease of blood glucose levels as compared to usual sugar are avoided.

-Glycogen Storage: Sugar, in the form of glucose, that is not currently needed by the body is broken down and stored as glycogen in the liver and muscles. This glycogen acts as a reserve energy source. If your body has a demand for energy, e.g. while doing physical exercise or between meals, your glycogen is decomposed into glucose for immediate use.

2. Supporting Metabolic Processes

Carbohydrates do more than just provide energy. They are implicated in at least some of the body's metabolic pathways. For instance, carbohydrate metabolism is involved in the synthesis of certain molecules, such as nucleic acids (DNA and RNA) and amino acids, which are involved in the synthesis, maintenance and repair of the tissues. Moreover, carbohydrates are involved in fat-sparing metabolism and sufficient amount of carbohydrate supply could help the body to burn FA efficiently.

3. Regulating Protein Metabolism

Among the significant functions of carbohydrates is protein metabolism. When not enough stored carbohydrates are available to fuel energy demands, protein is also mobilized to be catabolism for energy. This can in turn, result in a breakdown of muscular growth and repair when the body is forced to prioritize the use of amino acids (the building blocks of protein) for energy rather than massing them for repair.

Carbs protect protein from catabolism into energy use, which in turn gives amino acids in protein an available supply to repair tissue and promote building muscle. This would in no sense be less relevant to the patient or the athlete/exerciser to acquire muscle mass either by building or preserving muscle mass.

4. Providing Dietary Fiber

Carbohydrates also have dietary fiber (derived from plant foods, fruit, vegetables, legumes and cereals). Fiber is indigestible by the human but it is known to be important in the function of digestion (i.e. It has a function in regulation of bowel function e.g. prevention of constipation as well as contributing to the feeling of satiety in the regulation of appetite.

Fiber is also vital to cardiovascular health due to its ability to lead to a reduced cholesterolemia by cholesterol complexation and by inhibiting its systemic uptake. Soluble fiber and insoluble fiber, which are two fiber types, each carry their own benefits. Soluble fiber helps regulate blood sugar levels and reduce cholesterol, while insoluble fiber helps maintain bowel regularity.

image credit: FREEPIK

Section 2: What Carbs Can’t Do for Your Body

Although carbohydrates are required for the many physiological functions, carbohydrates are not equipped with all the power. The role of carbohydrates in the body is loaded with misconceptions regarding the functions of carbohydrates in the body, as well as in what carbohydrates are incapable of performing.

1. Carbs Can't Build Muscle Mass

Although energy dissipated by carbohydrates is high, carbohydrates do not have a direct muscle mass building effect. Protein is the macro-nutrient allowing the building and repair of muscles. While the primary role of carbohydrates is in the energy for exercises and movement, protein serves the functions of repair of the worked muscle tissue and growth of the previously worked down muscle tissue by means of exercises.

-Misconception: Peculiarly, many people think that high carbohydrate intake will actually cause more muscle mass. While carbohydrates play a role in providing energy, protein and related strength training, protein is the primary fabricator of muscle tissue.

-The Role of Protein: Protein has amino acid which human body utilizes for repair and rebuilding of damaged muscle tissue. Muscle growth and repair will be impaired together even if carbohydrate is sufficient, when protein is not sufficient.

2. Carbs Can't Replace Fats for Hormone Regulation

Although carbohydrate is used for energy generation, fat is the macro-nutrient that is characterized by hormone regulation and secretion. Lipids are required for the synthesis of steroid hormones, including estrogen, testosterone and cortisol. These hormones mediate a broad range of physiological processes, including metabolism, stress response and reproduction.

-The Role of Fats: Important fatty acids (omega-3 and omega-6) play a particularly critical role for the regulation of hormonal homeostasis. In the case that the body is deficient in fat, hormone systems may be dysregulated and result in low energy states, menstrual dysfunction in females, and a heightened sensitivity to stress.

What Happens Without Fats? When people consume a diet with a very low fat content, there are hormonal imbalances impacting mood, fertility and immune function, etc. Although carbohydrates are necessary energy sources, they are unable to substitute the role of fats in hormone regulation.

3. Carbs Can't Provide Essential Fatty Acids or Protein

The essential protein and fatty acids required for "health and proper functioning of the body" are not found in carbohydrates.

-Essential Fatty Acids: They are food components which the body does not synthesize and must be supplied through the diet. Omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids are important to brain function and anti-inflammatory and cell structure functions, hormone activity, and also membrane integrity. These fatty acids need to be obtained through diet, i.e. through consumption of food, e.g. fish oily, flaxseed, chia seed, walnut, and others.

-Proteins: Protein is composed of amino acids, and certain amino acids are teratogenic, i.e., they must be consumed from food. Sources of protein are meat, dairy, legumes, lentils and some grains. But, on their own, carbs are not an amino acid deliverer and though, they can provide energy, they also do not meet the body need for protein.

4. Carbs Can't Prevent or Cure Disease

For example, carbohydrates, especially in the form of fiber are effective for prevention disease, but direct therapy cannot be provided by carbohydrates. Carbohydrates have no medicinal properties and consequently, carbohydrates cannot be used as an alternative to an appropriate therapy or medication for the treatment of cancer, diabetes or cardiovascular diseases.

-Fiber and Health: Although fiber is of great interest in the prevention of cardiovascular diseases and gastrointestinal illness, fiber does not cure existing diseases. A high fiber diet can be used to reduce the risk of heart diseases by decreasing cholesterol levels, by enhancing the blood glucose control and by enhancing the gut microbiota in general.

-Chronic Diseases: High consumption of refined carbohydrates (e.g., sugar beverages, processed foods) may be one of the hallmarks of risk for developing chronic diseases like type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, obesity and others. I.e. because fiber-containing carbohydrates hold the promise of reducing disease, they are not curative.

5. Carbs Can't Build Strong Bones

Although carbohydrates have a bearing on general health, they are not directly related to the creation or reinforcement of healthy characterized bones. Bone health depends upon a number of factors, of which calcium, vitamin D, and magnesium are important.

-Bone Health: Calcium and vitamin D are redeposited to an extent that ensures the possibility of the absolute calcium absorption and osteogenesis. If supply of these nutrients is removed then bone can become thinner and thus, more fragile. Carbohydrates are not involved in the formation of bones and thus, cannot act as a replacement to other dietary components required to maintain healthy bones.

-Exercise and Bones: Weight-bearing (walking, running, exercising with weights) exercise, among other physical activities, can be beneficial in maintaining bone health. Although carbohydrates could supply energy for muscles, carbohydrates cannot have direct effect on bone strength.

6. Carbs Can't Hydrate the Body

Carbohydrate exerts a secondary effect in hydration but does not hydrate the human body as water or electrolytes do. Although carbs in the homologous form of glycogen are stored with water in the body (i.e., 1 gm glycogen binds to 3 gm water) they do not fulfill the body's requirement for sufficient hydration.

-Hydration Needs: Water, not carbs is essential for maintaining hydration levels. Water is necessary for temperature homeostasis, digestion, nutrient transport/removal and waste removal of the body. Carbohydrate is a possible mediator for fluid retention through glycogenolysis but cannot be replaced by water or electrolytes inside the body.

-Importance of Water: Ensuring adequate water intake is essential for overall health. While carbohydrates are being consumed for energy replenishment, effective hydration should be obtained from sufficient water and electrolyte drinks.

image credit: FREEPIK

Section 3: Debunking Carbohydrate Myths

Carbohydrates are often surrounded by myths and legends in health and nutrition. Believe it or not there are several of the most common myths and these should be debunked.

1. The Myth of the "No-Carb" Diet

The "no-carb" diet has gained some adherents in some circles, purportedly for weight loss or for health indications, etc. Nevertheless, it is not possible to completely avoid consumption of carbohydrates from the diet and it is not desirable. Carbohydrates are energy sources, whereas carbohydrate withdrawal can result in nutritional deficiencies.

-Healthy Carb Choices: The secret to healthy dieting does not lie in deprivation of carbs but in the selection of the proper kind of carbs. Complex carbohydrates (whole grains, vegetables and beans) provide prolonged energy supply, high fiber and are rich in vitamins and minerals that are required for survival.

2. The Myth That Carbs Cause Weight Gain

While it is also true that excessive consumption of processed (e.g., sugar) carbohydrates leads to obesity, carbohydrates do not cause obesity. Weighting is defined as calorie intake, but not expressed. Indeed, a large number of whole-food carbohydrates (e.g., fruits, vegetables, whole grains) is able to contribute to weight loss by providing satiety for a longer period of time through their high fiber content.

3. The Myth That All Carbs Are the Same

Not all carbs are created equal. There are simple sugars (e.g., sugar in candy or coke or in bread products) and complex sugars (e.g., in grains, legumes, and vegetables). Simple carbohydrates have been known to increase blood glucose levels and lead to energy drops while complex carbohydrates are slowly degraded and keep a constant level of energy supplies.

-Focusing on Whole Foods: The key is to focus on whole food sources of carbs. Foods high in nutrients and with little processing. Composed of these complex sugars, they are more healthy than "refined" ones.

Whole Grain Pasta buying link is given below:

CLICK HERE

Conclusion: Which of the following is not a function of carbohydrates?

Carbohydrates are the main macro-nutrient in the food of the organism and as such they supply the organism with energy, help with metabolic activity and maintain a healthy gut, etc. However, they are not without their limitations. Carbohydrates are not able to generate skeletal muscle mass, regulate hormones or specifically cure disease. They are also relevant to energy, but they have to be combined with the other macro-nutrients, i.e. protein and fat, if a person wants to be healthy.

The key to eat well is to understand the role of healthy (i.e carbs supplied by whole food) and the intake of quantities and ratio of carbs to protein and fats. By disentangling fact and fiction in the context of carbohydrate intake, you can better understand the actual role carbohydrates play in keeping you well and avoid pitfalls and misconceptions.

-The bottom line: Carbs are not a jack of all trades, but they can contribute to energy requirements, metabolic functions and digestive well being. It's a question of moderation, a question of what, healthy balanced dietary sources and balanced diet which is good for balanced health.